Back to All Brands

Home & Cleaning(Consumable Product)

Who Gives A Crap

Toilet paper company donating 50% of profits to build toilets and improve sanitation worldwide. 100% recycled or bamboo products with plastic-free packaging.

106/165
Making Progress

Detailed Scorecard Breakdown

Click each category to see individual criteria scores

A: Circular Economy

Priority #1
30/30
Product certified compostable/biodegradable100% recycled/FSC bamboo/bagasse — all compostable/biodegradable
8/8
Plastic-free + compostable/recyclable packagingPlastic-free paper wrappers, zero plastic per order
7/7
Concentrated refill format or bulk refillSubscription bulk-refill model (24-48 rolls)
6/6
Full material/ingredient transparencyFull material transparency, multi-certification
5/5
Verified recycled content (50%+ with GRS)100% recycled or 100% FSC-certified bamboo
2/2
Zero packaging waste (plastic-free, compostable)Fully plastic-free packaging
2/2

B: Transparency & Data

Priority #2
21/35
Published Life Cycle Assessment (ISO 14040/14044)Third-party LCA: 70,605 tCO2e in 2022
5/10
Scope 3 emissions measured & publicly disclosedShipping carbon neutral, full S3 not itemized
5/10
Annual sustainability report with YoY trackingB Corp Impact Report 2024 with quantified metrics
7/7
Public supplier list (tier 1 & 2)No public supplier list
0/4
Third-party data verificationB Corp 108.9, FSC Chain-of-Custody, third-party LCA
4/4

C: Certifications

Priority #3
14/18
qualityB Corp 108.9 (Diff 5)
8/8
volume3 verified certifications
4/7
diversity2 categories: Environmental, Material/Circular
2/3

D: Climate & Renewables

Priority #4
6/27
onsite renewableNo on-site renewable
0/7
climate statusCarbon-neutral shipping via verified offsets since 2020
2/10
emissions reductionDocumented YoY reduction via B Corp report
3/6
renewable procurementSome renewable via offset programs
1/4

E: Business Model

Priority #5
20/20
Concentrated formula, promotes using less50% profits to water/sanitation ($20M+ AUD)
7/7
Lowest-impact format, longest-lastingRecycled paper and bamboo with documented supply chain
5/5
Company-wide practices100% of products are sustainable
4/4
Stable range, no trend-driven launchesStable range since 2013
2/2
Packaging take-back or refill partnershipSubscription refill model
2/2

F: Social Responsibility

Priority #6
4/15
Living wage certificationNo living wage cert for manufacturing partners
0/5
Independent factory audits with public resultsThird-party factory audits confirmed for China partners
4/4
Worker safety certifications (ISO 45001)No ISO 45001
0/3
Supply chain transparency (tier 2+)FSC Chain-of-Custody but no tier 2+ visibility
0/3

G: Impact Claims

Priority #7
8/10
Specific quantified claims70,605 tCO2e, £9.8M donated, 845K people impacted
4/4
Material composition transparency100% recycled OR 100% FSC bamboo disclosed
3/3
No vague greenwashing termsSome past packaging greenwashing allegations
1/3

H: Regenerative (Bonus)

Priority #8
3/5
Ecosystem restoration verified$20M+ AUD to WASH programs, 845K people with water access
3/3
Zero waste or water positive programsNo operational water positive program
0/2

Key Findings

Strengths

  • +50% of profits donated to water/sanitation ($20M+ AUD)
  • +B Corp 108.9 with FSC Chain-of-Custody
  • +Perfect circular economy score — plastic-free, recycled, subscription refill

Areas for Improvement

  • -No Scope 3 formally disclosed
  • -No on-site renewable energy
  • -No public supplier list or living wage cert

Certifications Held

  • B Corp 108.9
  • FSC Chain-of-Custody
  • Carbon Neutral shipping

Rating Methodology

Scoring Categories (165 pts total)

  • A: Circular Economy - 30 pts (Priority #1)
  • B: Transparency & Data - 35 pts (Priority #2)
  • C: Certifications - 25 pts (Priority #3)
  • D: Climate & Renewables - 25 pts (Priority #4)
  • E: Business Model - 20 pts (Priority #5)
  • F: Social Responsibility - 15 pts (Priority #6)
  • G: Impact Claims - 10 pts (Priority #7)
  • H: Regenerative - 5 pts (Bonus)

Tier Ratings

  • Tier 1: 145-165 pts (Verified Leader)
  • Tier 2: 115-144 pts (Certified Sustainable)
  • Tier 3: 85-114 pts (Making Progress)
  • Tier 4: 55-84 pts (Early Stage)
  • Tier 5: 0-54 pts (Needs Improvement)

This brand: Tier 3 (Making Progress, 85-114 pts)Some circularity, transparency efforts, certifications present, solid sustainability foundation.